Pentecost at Kirtland
Written by Alisa Davis
The spirit of the lord as on the day of Pentecost was profusely poured out. . . we had a most glorious and never to be forgotten time.
Benjamin Brown
How often do you think about the events at Pentecost in Acts 2, or do you even recall what it is? Or perhaps you wonder why it matters since it occurred in the last dispensation before the great apostasy. On March 27, 1836, at the dedication of the Kirtland Temple, events occurred that were readily compared by those who were there to what was experienced in Acts 2 at Pentecost. A few days later, as supernatural events continued to occur, Joseph Smith would declare to 300 Elders in the church that “the organization of the church was now complete” [1]. The dedication of the Kirtland Temple was marked by supernatural events and visitors that were not seen to the same degree at other temple dedications. It was a special moment in time that shares important commonalities with both Pentecost and Sinai. The second chapter of Acts details how the disciples were gathered together and the place where they were was filled with the sound of rushing wind, fire appeared above their heads, and they began to spontaneously speak in languages they had never learned. This was witnessed by a multitude of people, many of whom were immediately baptized. An astonishing number of 3,000 believers were added in a single day to Jesus’s little band of followers; this was a seminal moment in the beginning of Christ’s church in that dispensation and has been called the “birthday” of the Church. The day and location in which this event occurred was already a significant day, one of three mandatory pilgrimage days to the Temple for Jewish males 50 days after Passover called Shavu’ot, or the Feast of First Fruits. Shavu’ot is a harvest festival that also memorializes God’s establishment of the national covenant with Israel which inaugurated the prior dispensation with Moses at Mount Sinai.
Pentecost and Sinai are two events that are closely linked to each other and form a framework we can use to understand the significance of what happened at Kirtland and something of the role the miraculous or supernatural plays in our faith. Because I came as an adult to the LDS faith from other Christian churches, I have been exposed to many of the different ways that Christian denominations understand the Holy Ghost, spiritual gifts, and the supernatural. One of my earlier experiences as a teenager was in the youth program of an Assemblies of God church; the AoG denomination is a loose coalition of independent churches that are “Pentecostal” in their doctrine. Among Christian denominations “Pentecostal” is a descriptor that applies to churches that emphasize the personal experience of the baptism of the Holy Ghost for each believer. This personal experience is considered to be essential as evidence of Christian faith and is expected to manifest through spiritual gifts and experiences of the supernatural. Because this movement within the Christian faith takes as its inspiration the events of Acts 2 the ability to speak in tongues has primary significance. But this isn’t the tongues of Acts 2 where people from other nations can understand what is being said, in Pentecostal churches it has morphed into what is often called a “personal prayer language” that sounds like gibberish to an outside observer. It is so important that believers have a “personal prayer language” that at some church gatherings and youth events people are encouraged, and in some cases, not allowed to leave the meeting until they speak in “tongues”. The ability to speak in a gibberish-esqe language while in a state of ecstasy is treated as a litmus test for the quality of a person’s faith and whether or not they have been “baptized” by the Holy Ghost. I have known people who have faked it just to be able to leave a meeting, and in my case I was told to “fake it ‘till you make it”, essentially, “speak gibberish in faith and it will eventually become a real prayer language when God sees your faith”. I understand how this is so wholly outside the experience of a member of the LDS faith that it likely is baffling, strange, and perhaps you find it a bit uncomfortable. In my opinion I have found that the LDS church accomplishes what Pentecostalism is aiming at – which is a lived experience of the gift of the Holy Ghost in the believer’s life that can, and frequently does, manifest in the supernatural acquisition of other languages, signs, wonders, and miracles. I have heard more regular testimonies of the Spirit manifesting itself in the everyday life of members of this church than I ever did in the many years I spent in other churches that eagerly sought such things. This is not to say that miracles and signs did not happen in these other churches, but they do seem to be more commonplace among Latter Day Saints, to the extent that they may be mistaken for being mundane or un-miraculous. Large “flashy” manifestations of the supernatural are rare and based on what I understand of history and from the witness of scripture, serve a specific purpose.
In the events at Mount Sinai, beginning in Exodus 19, there are several key details that will play into the events at Pentecost. The people of Israel arrived at Sinai “in the third month” after leaving Egypt, tradition puts the exact date at 50 days after the first Passover when Moses ascended the mountain to speak with God. Mountains and high places are recognized as being places where temples are built or are stand-ins for temples themselves, due to their height mountains are places where Heaven and Earth meet. So when God descended on Sinai it could be said that he dwelt at the Temple of Sinai even before the Divine Presence took up residence in the Tabernacle or Solomon’s Temple. The nation of Israel was commanded to purify themselves in preparation and when God did descend on the mountain he “descended upon it in fire: and the smoke thereof ascended as the smoke of a furnace”. God then proceeded to speak the 10 commandments and “all the people saw the thunderings, and the lightnings, and the noise of the trumpet, and the mountain smoking”. In the Hebrew, the verse literally reads, “And all the people saw the voices and the torches.” [2] In the traditions of the Jewish people the scriptures are describing when each individual at Sinai “not only heard the Lord’s voice, but actually saw the sound waves as they emerged from the Lord’s mouth. They visualized them as a fiery substance. Each commandment that left the Lord’s mouth traveled around the entire camp and then came back to every Jew individually” [3]. Following the giving of the 10 commandments God spoke further with Moses and gave more specific commandments that formed the basis for Israel’s covenant with God and their national constitution as a new nation. This was the moment when, in my opinion, that dispensation officially began. It built upon previous dispensations and laid the foundation for the next; previously the word of God existed spiritually but at Sinai it was made material and existed in stone and as physical laws. In the next dispensation it would be made flesh.
At the time of the first Apostles the commandments of God had been made manifest in all their perfection in the person of Jesus, the word of God at Sinai had become flesh but that flesh could not dwell with us forever until the time of the Messianic Era. So Christ instructed his disciples not to go home to Galilee but to stay in Jerusalem until they are baptized by the Holy Ghost. They are told to “camp out” in the city where the “mountain of the Lord”, the Temple, was. This may have been practical advice on the part of Christ because in just 10 days would be the second major pilgrimage feast mandatory for all Jewish men, the roads and city would have been clogged with pilgrims for days before and after, and it was crucial that the disciples be at the festival. 50 days after Passover all Jewish men would be purifying themselves to go to the Temple and celebrate Shavu’ot, the Feast of First Fruits. Jews from all over the known world would have filled the temple courts, an area the size of 37 acres with the Temple in the center. The Apostles likely gathered for the Temple services at Solomon’s Colonnade, the area on the east side of the court of Gentiles marked by a double row of columns, as this was where Christ often taught during his ministry and where the Apostles were later known to frequently gather.
- As the courts filled with pilgrims on the Temple Mount a “sound from Heaven as of a mighty rushing wind” filled the house of the Lord and tongues of fire appeared above the heads of the disciples as they gave voice to the words of God “as the spirit gave them utterance”. The flames of fire would have been immediately recognized as a supernatural manifestation like what happened at Sinai and the rushing wind coming into the eastern colonnade would have been also recognizable as the fulfillment of Ezekiel’s prophecy of the return of the Divine Presence to the Temple that had departed when Solomon’s Temple was destroyed [4]. Only this time the voice that was heard was not God uttering the commandments of the Torah to all men, but men speaking of Christ the living Torah. And the temple that was filled by the Divine Presence was not a building but the disciples themselves. These supernatural manifestations were so shocking and incomprehensible to some that the only explanation they could give was to accuse the disciples of Christ of being drunk. Yet when Peter, full of a courage and authority he’d never displayed before, stood up and quoted the prophet Joel, I imagine that nearly everyone within hearing range of him was converted as 3,000 people were immediately baptized into the fellowship of Christ. Thus began a new dispensation.
Then at Kirtland, as at Sinai and Pentecost, a young community of baptized believers gathered together at a Temple to wait upon the Lord. As they worshiped God in obedience to the “Torah” (which means teachings or instruction) revealed to the Prophet, the Divine Presence again manifested itself as tongues of fire resting upon the church leaders as at Pentecost, and as a pillar of cloud and fire resting on the Temple as at Sinai [1]. As the men prophesied and spoke in tongues there were those who thought they were drunk, just as at Pentecost. The Spirit of God was making direct connections to the establishment of the two prior dispensations, and this was not missed by those who were there. Elder Benjamin Brown recorded; “There the Spirit of the Lord, as on the day of Pentecost, was profusely poured out. Hundreds of Elders spoke in tongues. . . Angels were seen by numbers present, and the first endowments were received” [5]. The Prophet Joseph Smith declared at this time that the organization of the church was complete and shortly after was visited by Christ, Moses, Elias, and Elijah. Manifestations which had not occurred at the commencement of the previous dispensation, and essential keys were conferred that were needed to forward the cause of the gospel on earth.
Each dispensation built on the one before it and was inaugurated by an outpouring of the Spirit that manifested in very specific and dramatic ways. The purpose has always been to establish the Kingdom of Heaven on earth, first as a physical nation that gave birth to a spiritual nation that will one day be both a physical and spiritual nation when Christ returns to establish the Messianic Kingdom. The Spirit at Pentecost was poured out as a guarantee, or down payment, on the promise of the Messianic Kingdom as prophesied by Joel, Isaiah, and others, where all of mankind will be filled with the knowledge of God, there will be peace on earth, and God will once again dwell with man. What happened at Kirtland was a promise and a reminder that the fulfillment of a spiritual and physical Kingdom of Heaven on earth is eminent as we spread the gospel in these latter days. “When understood from this perspective, the significance of the Holy Spirit is not signs, wonders, miracles, and gifts. The significance of the Holy Spirit is that it betokens the kingdom of heaven. The miracles and gifts are not the main things. The miracles indicate the presence of the Spirit, and the Spirit indicates the presence of the kingdom” [6]. So while gifts like speaking in tongues, supernatural manifestations, and even miracles may occur when the Holy Ghost is bestowed upon believers, it is because the Spirit is about the business of establishing the Kingdom. I’ve observed members at times express the feeling or idea that the experience of the miraculous or supernatural in their lives is dependent upon their faithfulness to their covenants. This is the same error the Pentecostals of my youth made. Spiritual gifts and supernatural manifestations are not meant to be viewed as proof of the greatness of our own faith or evidence of God’s presence in our lives. Our faithfulness to our Father and our covenants and his love and concern for us are totally separate from whether or not we receive a particular spiritual gift or see prayer answered in a miraculous way. When we are about the work of the Kingdom, doing our part to bring Heaven to earth, the supernatural will be the seal on our efforts as the Spirit empowers us and sees fit. As young men and women go on their mission they have been known to be empowered with the gift of tongues, learning foreign languages at a rapid rate. As men exercise their priesthood to bless others miraculous healings and words of knowledge have been known to occur. As women exercise their own priestess-hood insight, peacemaking, and visions have been granted. These are just a few examples from the many testimonies I have heard since joining the church. When we are about God’s business, the Spirit will become manifest in ours.
Resources
- https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/history/saints-v1/21-the-spirit-of-god?lang=eng
- https://ffoz.org/messiah/articles/fire-on-the-mountain
- Weissman, Moshe. The Midrash Says, Shemos, Bnai Yaakov Publications. (1995) p. 182 citing Midrash Chazit.
- https://ffoz.org/messiah/articles/a-pledge-and-a-promise
- https://archive.org/details/testimoniesfortr01brow/page/11/mode/1up
- https://ffoz.org/messiah/articles/a-pledge-of-what-is-to-come/
Prepare with Us
The Honey and Lilies Blog is dedicated to helping your prepare spiritually, mentally and emotionally, physically, and temporally.
Tune In
Join Meghan each week for inspiring messages, and diving into the scriptures to help you live the gospel, seek truth, and become a true disciple of Christ.
Dive Deeper
We are excited to offer online, self-paced courses to help you deepen your faith and understanding of the gospel and your covenants.